First and foremost, it’s not the Arkham series. That’s still the standard for Batman (and probably all superhero) games.
But Batman: the Telltale Series is great in all the ways that it’s different. It’s not a button masher at all, but still very much a Batman game.
The beauty of this game is in how it makes you consider the ramification for each aspect of the character. What type of Dark Knight are you? A completely psychopathic ‘beat all criminals to near death’ like Batfleck, or do you see the Dark Knight as more of a symbol and a scare tactic like Malik Aziz?
Then there’s the public persona of Bruce Wayne. Do you carry yourself like an oddball recluse like Michael Keaton, or do you lean more into the pretentious, flippant guy in the Armani suits who has a taste for beautiful women, like Malik Aziz?
And there’s the aspect the movies rarely dig deep into: the legacy/relationship of the Wayne family to Gotham. You’re the oldest of old money. Your parents were well known philanthropists. As the last standing Wayne, did your parents’ murder make you into an idealist like Batman Begins Christian Bale? Or are you a pragmatist who understands how the sausage gets made on the highest levels, like Malik Aziz?
The game branches out based on the choices you make, Choose Your Adventure style. It’s a mental exercise in making important choices on instinct and dealing with the ramifications (like life), not a brawler. (So you can’t really ‘die’ as much as not finish fights as quickly. Not like you’d lose anyway, you’re Batman right?)
High recommend here. Must play if you’re a Dark Knight fan.